Dark circles under the eyes (mata panda): pigment, shadow or vessels, and which kind needs a doctor
Dark circles are rarely just tiredness. Pigment, a shadow from the shape of the lid, and vessels showing through thin skin look alike and need different answers, and one rare pattern needs an eye doctor.
Consultant Ophthalmologist and Oculoplastic Surgeon · MMC 66025 · NSR 143681 · Consultations from early 2027
- Dark circles come from pigment in the skin, shadow from the shape of the lid and cheek, or vessels and fluid showing through thin skin, and many people have a mix.
- A dermatology review says lack of sleep, stress, alcohol and smoking are named as contributors 'although not clinically substantiated', so sleep alone is not a proven cause.
- A Singapore study of 200 people with periorbital hyperpigmentation found the vascular type commonest at 41.8 per cent and the constitutional type commonest in Indian and Malay patients.
- Lower eyelid surgery can address shadow cast by fat or excess skin, but it does not lighten pigment inside the skin, which is a dermatology question.
- A blue-grey patch on one side, or a dark patch that is changing, is not an ordinary dark circle and needs an examination.
"Mata panda" is the name most Malaysians give to a dark ring under the eye, and it is usually blamed on too little sleep. Sometimes sleep is part of it. More often the colour comes from one of three things sitting in different layers of the lower lid: pigment in the skin, a shadow cast by the shape of the lid and cheek, or blood vessels showing through thin skin. They look alike in a selfie. They do not respond to the same thing.
This is the one general page I have written on the subject, so it sorts the causes, says what creams and sleep do and do not change, and says plainly what an oculoplastic surgeon, a surgeon who specialises in the eyelids and the tissues around the eye, can and cannot alter. The wider picture of why eyes look tired is in what actually makes eyes look tired, and I will not repeat it here.
Why do I have dark circles under my eyes, and is it always tiredness?
No. Dark circles are multifactorial, meaning several causes can overlap. A 2016 review by Vrcek and colleagues in the Journal of Cutaneous and Aesthetic Surgery describes them as the result of deep facial anatomy, soft tissue changes and the skin itself, and says that understanding the anatomy is crucial to working out which one you have.
The reason is the skin. The lower eyelid skin is among the thinnest on the body, with very little tissue underneath, so whatever lies below it, muscle, vessels, a groove in the bone, shows through. A dermatology review of periorbital hyperpigmentation, the medical name for darkening around the eyes, lists the same group of causes: inherited tendency, excess pigment, darkening after inflammation, swelling, prominent vessels, and shadowing from skin laxity or a tear trough, the groove that runs from the inner corner of the eye towards the cheek.
The same review says lack of sleep, stress, alcohol and smoking are often named as contributors, "although not clinically substantiated". I would put that on the table honestly: tiredness may make a dark circle look worse, but it is not a proven cause on its own.
Which kind do I have: pigment, shadow or visible vessels?
A look in the mirror can give a first guess, and only a first guess. Pigment tends to look brown, shadow tends to shift with the light, and vessels tend to look bluish or purplish. These are rules of thumb, not a diagnosis.
- Light test. The Vrcek review notes that overhead lighting can worsen the appearance of dark circles, while direct light may mask it. If the dark ring fades when light falls straight onto your face, shadow is a large part of it.
- Stretch test. The dermatology review says manual stretching of the lower lid skin can help to tell true pigmentation from a shadow effect. If the colour stays when the skin is gently pulled flat, it points to pigment. If it softens, it points more to shape. That last step is my reading, not the review's wording.
- Colour test. The Vrcek review notes that thin, somewhat transparent lid skin gives little camouflage to the vessels and muscle beneath, which darkens its appearance, and that fluid collecting there often looks purplish. It also describes breakdown products of blood leaking from vessels, which add to visible pigment change.
Real life is a mix. In a Singapore dermatology clinic study that examined 200 people with periorbital hyperpigmentation, dermatologists judged the vascular type the commonest at 41.8 per cent, then constitutional (inherited) at 38.6 per cent, post-inflammatory at 12 per cent and shadow effects at 11.4 per cent. A surgeon would look at the same lids and may weigh the shape of the lid and cheek more heavily, which is why a proper assessment is done on the face, not from a photograph.
Is "bawah mata hitam" in brown skin usually pigment?
Often, but not always. In that Singapore study the vascular type was seen mainly in Chinese patients, and the constitutional, inherited type was commonest in Indian and Malay patients. The study was done in one clinic, so it describes who attended that clinic and is not a Malaysian prevalence figure.
Two everyday habits feed pigment in the skin of the lids. Allergic eczema, called atopic dermatitis, and allergic contact reactions can leave darkening behind after the inflammation settles. The dermatology review also says rubbing and scratching around the eyes can cause it. The practical point is a boring one: if the lids itch, treating the itch matters more than any cream aimed at the colour. A child's version of this, where the nose is the cause, is explained by Dr Chan Li Yen in dark circles under a child's eyes.
Sun on the lid skin also matters. The dermatology review says broad-spectrum sunscreen and UV-protective sunglasses are considered beneficial. That is the reason I suggest sunglasses for this concern before anything stronger.
Do creams, sleep and iron tablets change dark circles?
Partly, and only for the part that sits on the surface. A cream can act on pigment in the skin and on fine dryness. No cream reaches the groove beneath a tear trough or the fat behind the lid, and I explain why in why eye creams cannot fix what surgery fixes. Pigment-lightening treatment is a dermatology question. Dr Ong Jin Khang sets out the skin side in why dark circles are never a single problem with a single fix.
Better sleep is good for you and does no harm here, but as the review above says, its link to dark circles is not clinically substantiated. Iron is a question I will answer carefully. Neither of the two reviews I read lists iron deficiency as a cause of dark circles, and I did not find a trial showing that iron tablets lighten the skin under the eye. If you are tired, pale or breathless, that is a reason to see your own doctor for a blood test, and it is a separate matter from the dark ring.
Be wary of anything that promises one fix for every kind. The dermatology review reports that some patients with dark circles noted darker pigmentation after hyaluronic acid filler, so even a treatment aimed at shadow can change colour.
What can an oculoplastic surgeon change, and what can they not?
A surgeon can change shape, not inherited colour. If the dark ring is a shadow cast by a bulging fat pad, loose skin or a hollow, that is structural, and structure is the surgeon's territory. The dermatology review states that blepharoplasty, eyelid surgery, helps with dark circles caused by shadows cast by fat deposits or excess skin. The Vrcek review says lower blepharoplasty can be used for shadowing, and that a chemical peel or laser resurfacing can be added to treat pigment.
What surgery cannot do is lighten pigment that sits in the skin of the lid. That is the work of a skin doctor, and the dermatology review says various non-invasive lasers have been used successfully for periorbital hyperpigmentation. Which approach suits which skin is not my call to make for a skin I have not seen, and it is the reason these assessments are often shared between two doctors. Nor can anyone promise that a dark circle will not return.
If you want to know whether the cause is a hollow, a bag or both, tear trough hollowing and why it is not the same as eye bags sets out the difference, lower blepharoplasty for eye bags explains the operation, and the smile roll, or wo can explains why a bulge under the lashes is not always a bag. Every operation carries risk, and an assessment should include it.
When is a dark patch under the eye not a dark circle at all?
When it is on one side only, blue-grey, new or changing, or sits with swelling, pain or a change in vision. Those need an eye doctor, not a concealer.
A blue-grey patch on one side that spreads to the temple or upper lid may be nevus of Ota, a birthmark of pigment cells deeper in the skin, which is common in Asian populations and needs yearly eye pressure checks. Nevus of Ota and why that birthmark needs an eye doctor covers it. Puffy lids that persist, or a lid that sits higher than before, can be thyroid eye disease, which is a different problem from colour. Purple-black darkening after a knock, or with no knock at all, is bruising, and bruising around the eye with no injury lists causes that deserve an examination. A StatPearls chapter on the raccoon sign lists causes of bruising around both eyes other than trauma, among them amyloidosis and bleeding disorders. A dark spot on the lid itself that is growing, bleeding or changing is a different question, answered in eyelid skin changes that are not normal ageing. If it is the lid skin itself that has gone dark, rather than the area under the eye, that is covered in the article on a black or dark eyelid.
The action is the same each time: get it examined before you buy anything. The wider set of aesthetic topics is in the periorbital aesthetics section.
- The darkness is blue-grey, on one side only, or spreads onto the temple or upper lid.
- The darkening is new, is getting worse, or looks like bruising with no knock to the eye.
- The lids are persistently puffy, one lid sits higher than before, or one eye looks more forward.
- There is pain, a change in vision, double vision or a red, swollen lid.
- A dark spot on the lid is growing, bleeding or changing shape.
Questions patients ask
Several things, often together: pigment in the skin, shadow from a hollow or a bulge, and vessels or fluid showing through thin lid skin. A 2016 review says the cause is multifactorial. Lack of sleep is named as a contributor but is not clinically substantiated.
Mata panda is the Malay everyday name for dark circles under the eyes. Most are not a sign of illness. A one-sided blue-grey patch, new bruise-like darkening or lid swelling that does not settle needs an examination.
Not on its own. The dermatology review I read says lack of sleep, stress, alcohol and smoking are often mentioned but not clinically substantiated. Sleep is good for you, but a dark ring that stays after good sleep is usually pigment, shadow or vessels.
Only the part that sits in the surface of the skin, and only slowly. A cream cannot reach a hollow or fat behind the lid. Because the three causes differ, a cream suited to pigment will not change a shadow.
I could not find evidence that they do. Neither review I read lists iron deficiency as a cause of dark circles. If you feel tired, pale or breathless, see your own doctor for a blood test, which is a separate question.
Only the shadow part. Lower eyelid surgery can address shadow cast by fat or excess skin, according to the reviews. It does not lighten pigment in the skin, and no one can promise a dark circle will not return.
Dark circles are usually on both sides and sit in the hollow under the eye. Nevus of Ota is usually one-sided and blue-grey, and continues onto the temple, upper lid or cheek. It needs eye pressure checks, not a cream.
Yes. The dermatology review says darkening can follow atopic and allergic contact dermatitis, and that rubbing and scratching around the eyes can cause it. Treating the itch comes first.
Sources
- Sarkar R, Ranjan R, Garg S, Garg VK, Sonthalia S, Bansal S. Periorbital hyperpigmentation: a comprehensive review. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol 2016;9(1):49-55 (opens in a new tab)
- Vrcek I, Ozgur O, Nakra T. Infraorbital dark circles: a review of the pathogenesis, evaluation and treatment. J Cutan Aesthet Surg 2016;9(2):65-72 (opens in a new tab)
- Ranu H, Thng S, Goh BK, Burger A, Goh CL. Periorbital hyperpigmentation in Asians: an epidemiologic study and a proposed classification. Dermatol Surg 2011;37(9):1297-1303 (opens in a new tab)
- StatPearls (NCBI Bookshelf): Raccoon sign (opens in a new tab)
General information written by a consultant oculoplastic surgeon. It does not replace an examination. If you are worried about your eyes or eyelids, please see an eye doctor. Written and reviewed by Dr Catherine Chow, Consultant Ophthalmologist and Oculoplastic Surgeon, MMC 66025 · NSR 143681.
Bring the midnight questions.
Researching quietly is smart. When you're ready to ask out loud, Dr Catherine Chow will consult at Eagle Eye Centre Malaysia, Petaling Jaya, from early 2027.
Until then, you can follow her on Instagram, @drcatherinec (opens in a new tab).













