Dr Catherine ChowOculoplastic Surgeon
Lumps, lashes and lid margin

Air sirih for the eyes: betel leaf water for a stye, red or swollen eyelid, and why it should not go in the eye

Air sirih is a familiar home practice for a stye or a red eyelid. What the evidence says, why it should never go in the eye, and the warm compress that does help.

Consultant Ophthalmologist and Oculoplastic Surgeon · MMC 66025 · NSR 143681 · Consultations from early 2027

In short
  • The research on betel leaf, Piper betle, and eye infection that I could find is laboratory work, and I found no study of sirih water used on the lid or in the eye in patients.
  • Leaf water is not sterile, and the AAO says fungal keratitis can follow plant material entering the eye through an injury, so it should never go into the eye.
  • An untreated corneal ulcer can cause permanent vision damage, according to the AAO, so eye pain, blurred vision or light sensitivity after anything goes into the eye needs a doctor the same day.
  • A warm compress is what the NHS and AAO advise for a stye: a clean flannel in warm water, which the NHS says to hold for 5 to 10 minutes, 2 to 4 times a day, without bursting the stye.
  • A stye that is very painful, spreading, affecting vision or not improving after a few weeks needs a doctor, and so does any hot, red lid with fever.

A red, sore bump on the eyelid, and someone at home says: boil some sirih leaves and use the water. In Malay it is "air sirih untuk mata", and it is a practice many families know, passed from mothers and grandmothers who meant well. Nothing here is a criticism of them. The question is narrower and practical: does betel leaf water help a stye or a swollen lid, and is it safe near the eye? My answer is that there is no good evidence it helps, there are good reasons it should never go into the eye, and there is something simple that does shorten a stye. I cannot examine anyone through a page, so this is for choosing what to do at home and recognising when a doctor should see it.

Why do people use air sirih for a stye or a red eyelid?

Because sirih, the betel leaf, has long had a place in Malay home care, and a stye is the kind of problem people want to treat at once. A stye, called bintit or ketumbit in Malay, is a small, tender, red lump on the lid, where a tiny gland at the lash line has become infected. The lid is swollen, sore and sometimes itchy, and the eye may water.

The wish is a sensible one: do something now, with something familiar, rather than wait. The practical problem is only what the leaf water is, how it is made and where it goes. A leaf, boiled in a pot and cooled, is not a sterile liquid. That matters a great deal the moment any of it reaches the surface of the eye.

Does betel leaf water actually work for a stye?

There is no clinical evidence that it does. The research I could find on the betel plant, Piper betle, and eye infection is laboratory work. One study by Kwankaew and colleagues in Veterinary World in 2024 tested an ethanol extract of the leaf against Acanthamoeba, an amoeba that can infect the cornea, and against two bacteria, in laboratory cultures. It was done in the dish, not in people or animals, and an ethanol extract is not the same thing as leaf water boiled in a kitchen.

That distinction is the whole point. A substance that slows germs in a dish has not been shown to be safe or effective on a living eye or lid, where concentration, cleanliness and contact time all change the result. I would call such findings a reason for more research, not a reason to use leaf water at home. I found no study of sirih water used on the lid or in the eye in patients, so there is no dose, no preparation and no safety data that anyone could point to.

Why should sirih water never go in the eye?

Because the front of the eye, the cornea, is a clear, delicate surface, and anything that is not sterile can carry germs onto it. The AAO lists the causes of keratitis, an infection or inflammation of the cornea, and says fungal infection can follow plant material entering the eye through an injury, and that Acanthamoeba lives in fresh water and soil. Boiling kills many germs, but it does not leave a liquid that is sterile once it cools, is poured into a cup and touches a cloth or a finger. Tiny leaf fragments can also scratch the surface, which gives germs a way in.

The consequences of a corneal infection are not small. The AAO says an untreated corneal ulcer can cause permanent vision damage or blindness, and that symptoms include severe pain, redness, tearing, blurred vision and light sensitivity.

The wider pattern is also documented. In a study of 313 people with microbial keratitis in southern Uganda by Arunga and colleagues, 188 had used traditional eye medicine. They reached the hospital later, with a median of 18 days against 14 days, had larger ulcers and had worse vision when first seen and at three months. That study is from another country and covers many kinds of traditional medicines, not sirih, so I cite it for one narrow point: putting an unsterile remedy into an infected eye, and waiting, has a measurable cost.

Something that is helpful on a leaf is not automatically safe on an eye.

What actually shortens a stye, and what is safe on the lid?

A warm compress. That is the measure both the NHS and the AAO recommend, and it works because heat softens the thickened oil and pus so the blocked gland can drain by itself. The NHS describes a clean flannel soaked in warm water, held against the eye for 5 to 10 minutes, 2 to 4 times a day. The AAO describes 10 to 15 minutes at a time, 3 to 5 times a day, kept warm but never hot enough to burn the skin.

Some practical points follow. Use plain water that has been boiled and cooled until it is comfortably warm, and a clean cloth that is used once, then washed. Hold it against the closed lid. Do not add leaves. Wash your hands first. The NHS and the AAO both say not to burst a stye, and the NHS adds not to pull out the lash yourself, because that can spread the infection. The NHS also advises avoiding contact lenses and eye make-up until it has healed. The usual course is about a week, according to the NHS.

On the skin of the closed lid, outside the lash line, the question is one of skin, not of the eye. I would still say that no evidence supports leaf water there either, and any leaf can irritate skin, so the sensible choice is the compress. What should not happen is for any liquid to run into the open eye, which is easy to do when a lid is sore and the head is tilted. I describe the stye in more detail in how long a stye lasts and when to see a doctor, and the page on antibiotic drops and ointment for a stye explains what a doctor may add. A hard, painless lump that stays for weeks is more likely a chalazion, which is a different problem, covered in the chalazion guide.

What if sirih water has already gone into my eye?

Do not rub the eye, and watch it closely for the next day or two. It does not always cause harm, and nobody should be blamed for it. But the warning signs of a corneal infection are the ones the AAO lists: increasing pain, redness, a feeling that something is in the eye, discharge, blurred vision, light sensitivity and a white spot on the cornea.

If any of these appear, see an eye doctor the same day, and say what went into the eye. Telling the doctor exactly what it was and when helps them choose the right tests. Do not wait to see if it settles, and do not add more leaf water, drops or ointments in the meantime.

When is a red, swollen eyelid not a stye, and when should a doctor see it?

When it is very painful, spreading, or affecting vision. The NHS says to seek urgent medical help if the stye is very painful or swollen, affects your vision, produces pus, or the infection spreads to the eye or eyelid. It also says to see a doctor if it has not improved after a few weeks. A lump that is hard and not very painful is more likely a chalazion than a stye.

A hot, red, swollen lid with fever or a feeling of being unwell can be preseptal cellulitis, infection of the lid in front of the orbital septum, and I explain when it becomes an emergency in the preseptal cellulitis page. A painful one-sided rash can also be shingles, not a stye. Pain in the eye itself, or blurred vision, points to the cornea, not the lid.

In Malaysia, start with a family doctor or klinik kesihatan, and ask for a surat rujukan to an eye doctor if the problem is on the eye, not just the lid. For children, Dr Chan Li Yen at Little Eyes 101 writes about styes in children and what helps, which is useful for families. The wider topic is in the eyelid lumps and lashes section, and the hub, what makes eyes look tired.

See a doctor promptly if
  • The eye itself is painful, red, sensitive to light or the vision is blurred, especially after anything has gone into it.
  • The lid is very painful or swollen, has pus, or the redness is spreading.
  • You have a fever, or the eyelid is hot, tense and red.
  • A white spot is visible on the clear front of the eye.
  • A lump on the lid has not improved after a few weeks.

Questions patients ask

I would not use it in the eye. Leaf water is not sterile, and the AAO says plant material entering the eye can lead to fungal keratitis. I found no study of sirih water used in patients' eyes, so there is no safe preparation to point to.

There is no clinical evidence that it does. The betel leaf research I found was done in laboratory cultures, not in people. A warm compress is what the NHS and AAO advise for a stye.

A clean flannel soaked in warm water, held on the closed lid. The NHS says 5 to 10 minutes, 2 to 4 times a day, and the AAO says 10 to 15 minutes, 3 to 5 times a day. Do not burst the stye or pull out the lash yourself.

The NHS says styes typically clear up within about a week. See a doctor if it is not better after a few weeks, or sooner if it is very painful, swollen, affects vision or has pus.

Do not rub it, and watch for the next day or two. If you get pain, redness, light sensitivity, blurred vision or a white spot, see an eye doctor the same day and say what went into the eye. Do not add other drops or remedies in the meantime.

No. A hard lump that is not very painful may be a chalazion. A hot, red, swollen lid with fever can be preseptal cellulitis, and a painful one-sided rash can be shingles. If in doubt, ask a doctor.

There is no evidence that it helps, and any leaf can irritate skin. The compress is the better choice. If anything is used on the lid, it must not run into the open eye.

General information written by a consultant oculoplastic surgeon. It does not replace an examination. If you are worried about your eyes or eyelids, please see an eye doctor. Written and reviewed by Dr Catherine Chow, Consultant Ophthalmologist and Oculoplastic Surgeon, MMC 66025 · NSR 143681.

Consultation

Bring the midnight questions.

Researching quietly is smart. When you're ready to ask out loud, Dr Catherine Chow will consult at Eagle Eye Centre Malaysia, Petaling Jaya, from early 2027.